Skip to content

Best Underrated Horror Movies on Netflix You Need to Watch

Introduction:

Ah, the sweet, sweet terror of a good horror movie. But let’s be honest, sometimes you’ve exhausted all the well-known classics and are craving something new. Maybe you’ve already binged “The Conjuring” franchise for the millionth time or found yourself questioning the sanity of “The Babadook” (again). This is where Netflix’s hidden gems come in. We’re diving into the dark corners of the streaming service to unearth the best underrated horror movies waiting to be discovered. Prepare to be chilled, surprised, and maybe even a little bit terrified.

Table of Contents:

  1. Possum (2018): A Puppet Master’s Twisted Tale
  2. The Seasoning House (2012): A Silent Revenge With a Spine-Chilling Twist
  3. Would You Rather (2012): A Deadly Game With No Easy Answers
  4. Bonus Picks: Other Underrated Horror Gems
  5. Conclusion: Why Underrated Horror Matters

1. Possum (2018): A Puppet Master’s Twisted Tale

This first movie is one of the creepiest things I’ve ever seen. “Possum” tells the story of a puppet theater performer named Philip who returns to his childhood home, haunted by a horrifying, spider-like puppet named Possum. Philip believes Possum can “stalk children” and “eat them in their beds.” The film is a slow burn of psychological horror, punctuated by bursts of unsettling imagery and a chillingly ambiguous ending. “Possum” will leave you questioning reality and struggling to shake the unsettling images long after the credits roll.

2. The Seasoning House (2012): A Silent Revenge With a Spine-Chilling Twist

This unique film is about a deaf and mute orphan who witnesses her family brutally murdered by soldiers. She is sold into servitude at a secluded house (hence the name “The Seasoning House”) and forced to witness horrifying atrocities. The film uses the protagonist’s silence and perspective to create a terrifying atmosphere of isolation and vulnerability. “The Seasoning House” isn’t just about jump scares; it’s about the psychological and emotional horror of being trapped in a place where no one can hear your screams.

3. Would You Rather (2012): A Deadly Game With No Easy Answers

“Would You Rather” is a classic horror movie that centers on a woman who enters a deadly game of the same name. Her motivation is to win enough money to pay for her brother’s cancer treatment. However, the game’s “choices” are so horrifying that the line between good and evil becomes blurred.

4. Bonus Picks: Other Underrated Horror Gems

(This section will include a list of additional hidden gems on Netflix. Keep an eye out for recommendations like:

  • The Woman (2011): A brutal and unflinching look at a feral woman raised in the wilderness.
  • The Ritual (2017): A group of friends on a hiking trip find themselves stalked by a terrifying creature.
  • Veronica (2017): A Spanish horror film that explores the dangers of a Ouija board.

5. Conclusion: Why Underrated Horror Matters

Discovering hidden gems like these is a thrill. It’s a reminder that the horror genre is constantly evolving, pushing boundaries and offering new ways to scare us. These movies are not just entertaining; they are thought-provoking. They force us to confront our own fears and anxieties and remind us of the fragility of the human condition.

So, next time you’re looking for a horror movie, don’t just go for the familiar. Take a chance on an underrated gem and you might just find your new favorite scare.

Ah, the sweet, sweet terror of a good horror movie. But let’s be honest, sometimes you’ve exhausted all the well-known classics and are craving something new. Maybe you’ve already binged “The Conjuring” franchise for the millionth time or found yourself questioning the sanity of “The Babadook” (again). This is where Netflix’s hidden gems come in. We’re diving into the dark corners of the streaming service to unearth the best underrated horror movies waiting to be discovered. Prepare to be chilled, surprised, and maybe even a little bit terrified.

Table of Contents:

  1. Possum (2018): A Puppet Master’s Twisted Tale
  2. The Seasoning House (2012): A Silent Revenge With a Spine-Chilling Twist
  3. Would You Rather (2012): A Deadly Game With No Easy Answers
  4. Bonus Picks: Other Underrated Horror Gems
  5. Conclusion: Why Underrated Horror Matters

1. Possum (2018): A Puppet Master’s Twisted Tale

This first movie is one of the creepiest things I’ve ever seen. “Possum” tells the story of a puppet theater performer named Philip who returns to his childhood home, haunted by a horrifying, spider-like puppet named Possum. Philip believes Possum can “stalk children” and “eat them in their beds.” The film is a slow burn of psychological horror, punctuated by bursts of unsettling imagery and a chillingly ambiguous ending. “Possum” will leave you questioning reality and struggling to shake the unsettling images long after the credits roll.

2. The Seasoning House (2012): A Silent Revenge With a Spine-Chilling Twist

This unique film is about a deaf and mute orphan who witnesses her family brutally murdered by soldiers. She is sold into servitude at a secluded house (hence the name “The Seasoning House”) and forced to witness horrifying atrocities. The film uses the protagonist’s silence and perspective to create a terrifying atmosphere of isolation and vulnerability. “The Seasoning House” isn’t just about jump scares; it’s about the psychological and emotional horror of being trapped in a place where no one can hear your screams.

3. Would You Rather (2012): A Deadly Game With No Easy Answers

“Would You Rather” is a classic horror movie that centers on a woman who enters a deadly game of the same name. Her motivation is to win enough money to pay for her brother’s cancer treatment. However, the game’s “choices” are so horrifying that the line between good and evil becomes blurred.

4. Bonus Picks: Other Underrated Horror Gems

  • The Woman (2011): A brutal and unflinching look at a feral woman raised in the wilderness.
  • The Ritual (2017): A group of friends on a hiking trip find themselves stalked by a terrifying creature.
  • Veronica (2017): A Spanish horror film that explores the dangers of a Ouija board.

5. Conclusion: Why Underrated Horror Matters

Discovering hidden gems like these is a thrill. It’s a reminder that the horror genre is constantly evolving, pushing boundaries and offering new ways to scare us. These movies are not just entertaining; they are thought-provoking. They force us to confront our own fears and anxieties and remind us of the fragility of the human condition.

So, next time you’re looking for a horror movie, don’t just go for the familiar. Take a chance on an underrated gem and you might just find your new favorite scare.