Skip to content

The Mystery of the Borden Murders: Did Lizzie Borden Really Take an Axe?

The infamous Lizzie Borden case continues to captivate and intrigue people over 130 years after the tragic events of August 4, 1892. The brutal murders of Andrew and Abby Borden, and the subsequent trial of their daughter, Lizzie, have become a cornerstone of American true crime history. This blog post will delve into the facts, theories, and unanswered questions surrounding this enduring mystery, exploring the evidence, the trial, and the lasting legacy of the Borden murders.

Table of Contents

  1. The Events of August 4, 1892: A chilling morning in Fall River, Massachusetts.
  2. Lizzie Borden: The Prime Suspect: Examining the evidence against her.
  3. Alternative Theories and Suspects: Exploring other possibilities.
  4. The Trial and Acquittal: A verdict that divided the nation.
  5. The Legacy of Lizzie Borden: From infamous rhyme to tourist attraction.
  6. FAQ Section: Answers to common questions about the case.
  7. Conclusion: The enduring mysteries of the Borden murders.

The Events of August 4, 1892

The morning of August 4, 1892, began like any other in the Borden household in Fall River, Massachusetts. Andrew Borden, a successful businessman, left for work as usual, while his wife, Abby, remained at home. Around 11 am, a neighbor, Ms. Bridget Sullivan, discovered the bodies of Andrew and Abby Borden in their home. Both victims had been brutally murdered with a blunt instrument, believed to be an axe. The scene was gruesome, and the discovery sent shockwaves through the small community.

The initial investigation focused on the immediate family members. The primary suspect quickly became Andrew and Abby’s daughter, Lizzie Borden. Lizzie, a 32-year-old woman known for her quiet demeanor, was present in the house at the time of the murders. Her lack of an alibi, combined with her unusual behavior after the murders, raised suspicion among the investigators.

Lizzie Borden: The Prime Suspect

Lizzie Borden’s relationship with her father and stepmother was complex and strained. Andrew Borden was a stern and demanding man, and Lizzie had inherited a large sum of money from her mother, which her father had tried to claim. This financial dispute, coupled with the lack of an alibi, fueled speculation about Lizzie’s potential motive for the murders.

The prosecution’s case against Lizzie relied heavily on circumstantial evidence. The “bloodstained” dress, discovered in the attic of the Borden house, became a key piece of evidence. The dress, allegedly stained with blood matching Abby Borden’s, was presented as proof of Lizzie’s involvement. However, the defense argued that the stain was a result of paint, not blood, and that the dress had been hidden away in the attic for years.

Furthermore, Lizzie’s behavior after the murders was considered strange and suspicious by many. Witnesses reported her as being oddly calm and collected in the immediate aftermath of the murders. Her emotional detachment, coupled with her reluctance to assist with the investigation, raised further doubts about her innocence.

Alternative Theories and Suspects

Despite the evidence presented against Lizzie Borden, many people believe that she was wrongly accused and that the real killer was never brought to justice. Various alternative theories have been proposed over the years, each presenting a different perspective on the events of that fateful day.

One popular theory suggests that Lizzie had an affair and that her lover, fearing exposure, committed the murders. Another theory proposes that the murders were committed by an intruder who was seeking to rob the Borden household.

It’s important to note that no concrete evidence has been found to support any of these theories. However, they offer a different lens through which to view the case, highlighting the possibility of other suspects and motives.

The Trial and Acquittal

The trial of Lizzie Borden began on June 3, 1893, and lasted for six weeks. The prosecution’s case, relying on circumstantial evidence, struggled to convince the jury of Lizzie’s guilt. The defense, led by skilled lawyers, presented a compelling argument, casting doubt on the evidence and highlighting the lack of a definitive connection between Lizzie and the murders.

The jury, after deliberating for three days, returned a verdict of “not guilty” on June 20, 1893. The verdict sparked widespread controversy, dividing the public and fueling the debate about Lizzie Borden’s true role in the murders.

Despite her acquittal, Lizzie Borden never fully escaped the shadow of suspicion. She was forced to move from Fall River and spent the rest of her life trying to rebuild her reputation. The Borden murders, however, continued to haunt her and cemented her place in American true crime history.

The Legacy of Lizzie Borden: From Infamous Rhyme to Tourist Attraction

Despite being acquitted, Lizzie Borden never escaped the shadow of suspicion. Her life after the trial was filled with a relentless pursuit of regaining a normal existence. She moved to a different town, adopted a new name, and tried her best to live a private life. However, the public never forgot the name “Lizzie Borden.”

The case’s lasting impact is evident in the iconic “Lizzie Borden” rhyme, which became a popular nursery rhyme across the nation. This chilling ditty, often sung by children, reflects the enduring fascination with the case and the lingering suspicion surrounding Lizzie:

“Lizzie Borden took an axe
Gave her mother forty whacks
When she saw what she had done
She gave her father forty-one.”

The rhyme, though undoubtedly inaccurate, reflects the public perception of Lizzie as a cold-blooded killer. This perception was further fueled by the development of the Borden house into a tourist attraction. Visitors flock to the house, now a museum, eager to experience the location where the murders took place.

FAQ Section

The enduring fascination with the Borden murders has generated numerous questions over the years. Here are answers to some of the most common ones:

  • Was Lizzie Borden really guilty? This question remains unanswered and continues to be debated by historians and crime enthusiasts alike. The evidence presented during the trial was circumstantial, leaving room for doubt about Lizzie’s involvement.
  • What happened to the murder weapon? The actual murder weapon, the axe believed to have been used in the murders, was never found. This absence of a definitive physical link between Lizzie and the murders further fuels the debate surrounding her guilt or innocence.
  • Was Lizzie Borden a victim of prejudice? Some argue that Lizzie, as a young woman in a patriarchal society, was unfairly targeted and subjected to societal biases. The prosecution’s focus on her alleged motive, her inheritance from her mother, might suggest an underlying prejudice against women seeking financial independence.
  • What is the true story behind the “Lizzie Borden” rhyme? The rhyme, while widely circulated, is not based on any verified facts about the case. It is purely a fictionalized account that has become ingrained in popular culture.
  • Where can I learn more about the case? There are numerous resources available for those interested in learning more about the Borden murders. You can visit the Lizzie Borden House Museum, read biographies and articles about the case, and watch documentaries exploring the trial and its aftermath.


The Borden murders remain one of the most captivating and unsolved mysteries in American true crime history. The evidence against Lizzie Borden was circumstantial, leaving many questions unanswered and creating a lasting debate about her guilt or innocence. The case continues to fascinate and intrigue people over 130 years later, serving as a reminder that the human capacity for violence and the pursuit of justice can be complex and often elusive.

This blog post has only scratched the surface of this intricate case. We encourage you to continue your exploration, delve deeper into the facts, theories, and unanswered questions surrounding the Borden murders. Share your thoughts and theories in the comments below, and let’s continue to unravel the mysteries of this enduring case together.