Skip to content

The Delphi Murders: Who Killed Abby and Libby? A Comprehensive Look

The February 13, 2017, disappearance and murders of Abigail “Abby” Williams and Liberty “Libby” German in Delphi, Indiana, remain one of the most perplexing and unsettling mysteries in recent American crime history. This blog post delves into the case, exploring the evidence, analyzing potential suspects, and examining the ongoing search for justice. Join us as we piece together the puzzle of the Delphi murders and attempt to understand the tragedy that shocked a small town and captured the nation’s attention.

Table of Contents

  • The Victims
  • The Crime Scene and Evidence
  • The Investigation
  • Potential Suspects
  • Theories and Speculation
  • The Ongoing Search for Justice
  • FAQ Section
  • Conclusion

The Victims

Abby Williams and Libby German were two teenage girls, inseparable friends who shared a love for life, adventure, and each other. Abby, 13, was a bright and outgoing student known for her warm smile and contagious laughter. Libby, 14, was a creative and artistic soul, always expressing herself through photography and drawing. Their vibrant personalities and youthful spirit made their tragic deaths all the more heartbreaking.

On that fateful day, they decided to explore the scenic trails near the abandoned Delphi Historic Trails, unaware of the danger that awaited them. Their innocent outing turned into a nightmare, and their lives were tragically cut short.

The Crime Scene and Evidence

The bodies of Abby and Libby were discovered on February 14, 2017, near the abandoned railroad tracks close to the Delphi Historic Trails. The crime scene revealed a chilling scene, prompting investigators to delve into every detail in search of clues.

The evidence collected at the crime scene included:

  • Photographs: The girls’ phones were found at the scene, containing photographs of the alleged perpetrator, which were later released by the authorities.
  • Audio Recording: Libby’s phone captured a brief audio recording of a male voice, believed to be that of the killer, uttering the words, “Down the hill”. This audio recording became a critical piece of evidence in the investigation, sparking intense public interest.
  • Footprints: Investigators discovered footprints in the snow near the crime scene, providing valuable insights into the perpetrator’s movements and possibly their footwear.
  • Personal Belongings: The girls’ belongings, including backpacks and personal items, were recovered at the scene, aiding investigators in reconstructing their final moments.

The Investigation

The investigation into the Delphi murders was an extensive and challenging endeavor, involving the collaboration of numerous law enforcement agencies, including the Indiana State Police, the FBI, and local authorities. The investigation proceeded through various stages, with investigators meticulously scrutinizing evidence, conducting interviews, and pursuing numerous leads.

  • Public Appeal: The authorities released sketches and photos of the potential suspect based on the recovered evidence, including the photographs from the girls’ phones and the audio recording.
  • Tip Lines: A dedicated tip line was established, urging the public to come forward with any information that could help solve the case.
  • Digital Forensics: Investigators meticulously analyzed the girls’ phones, social media accounts, and other digital footprints, hoping to uncover crucial details about their movements and potential interactions with the perpetrator.
  • DNA Analysis: Evidence collected from the crime scene was subjected to DNA analysis, a crucial tool in identifying the perpetrator. However, the DNA results did not immediately yield a conclusive match.

Potential Suspects

Over the years, investigators have pursued various leads and investigated numerous individuals who were considered potential suspects in the Delphi murders. The lack of a definitive suspect has fueled speculation and generated intense public interest in the case.

The investigation has focused on several individuals, including:

  • The “Bridge Guy”: The unidentified man in the photographs from the girls’ phones, captured near the Monon High Bridge, became the focus of the investigation. He was described as a young adult with a slender build and possibly wearing a blue jacket and jeans.
  • Other Individuals: Aside from the “Bridge Guy”, other individuals have come under investigation, including those with potential connections to the victims, the crime scene, or who exhibited suspicious behavior during the investigation.

Theories and Speculation

The lack of a definitive suspect and the ongoing nature of the investigation have led to a flurry of theories and speculation surrounding the Delphi murders. These theories range from plausible to outlandish, reflecting the public’s desire to make sense of this tragedy and find answers.

Some of the prominent theories include:

  • The “Bridge Guy” as the Perpetrator: This theory, supported by the photographs and the audio recording, suggests that the “Bridge Guy” is the primary suspect. However, without a confirmed identification or concrete evidence linking him to the crime, this remains speculation.
  • Local Connection: Many believe that the perpetrator is someone from the local community, citing the familiar terrain and the seemingly random nature of the attack. This theory suggests that the perpetrator may have known the girls or had a motive connected to the Delphi area.
  • Serial Killer: Some experts have proposed the possibility of a serial killer being responsible, drawing comparisons to other unsolved cases. However, this theory remains speculative, as there is no definitive evidence to support it.
  • Random Act of Violence: Another theory suggests that the murders were a random act of violence, perhaps committed by an individual with a mental health condition or someone acting out of impulse. This theory, while plausible, lacks concrete evidence.

The Ongoing Search for Justice

Despite the passage of time and the ongoing investigations, the Delphi murders remain unsolved. The authorities, driven by the desire for justice for Abby and Libby, continue their tireless efforts to find the perpetrator.

  • Reward: A substantial reward, offered by various organizations and individuals, remains in place for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the killer. This financial incentive is intended to encourage anyone with knowledge of the case to come forward.
  • New Leads: Investigators regularly receive and review new tips and leads, constantly seeking new insights and connections. The relentless pursuit of justice ensures that the case remains active and under continuous scrutiny.
  • Public Awareness: The Delphi murders have received widespread media coverage, ensuring that the case stays in the public consciousness. This heightened awareness may lead to new witnesses or crucial information emerging over time.

FAQ Section

  • Who were Abby and Libby? Abby Williams and Libby German were two close friends, aged 13 and 14 respectively, who were tragically murdered in Delphi, Indiana, on February 13, 2017.
  • Where and when did the murders occur? The murders took place near the abandoned railroad tracks close to the Delphi Historic Trails in Delphi, Indiana, on February 13, 2017.
  • What evidence was found at the crime scene? Evidence included photographs of the potential suspect, an audio recording of a male voice, footprints in the snow, and personal belongings of the victims.
  • What does the audio recording contain? The audio recording captured on Libby’s phone features a male voice saying, “Down the hill.”
  • Who are the main suspects? The main suspect in the case is the unidentified man in the photographs, known as the “Bridge Guy.” Other individuals have also been investigated.
  • What are some of the theories about the case? Some theories include the “Bridge Guy” being the perpetrator, a local connection, a serial killer, or a random act of violence.
  • Is there any progress in the investigation? The investigation remains ongoing, with authorities pursuing new leads and seeking to solve the case.
  • What can I do to help solve the case? If you have any information, no matter how small, please contact the authorities. You can also stay informed about the case and share information with others.


The Delphi murders remain a poignant reminder of the fragility of life and the enduring mystery surrounding the case. While justice has yet to be served, the pursuit of truth and the quest for closure continue, fueled by the unwavering determination of law enforcement, the unwavering support of the community, and the enduring memory of Abby and Libby.

It is hoped that one day, the perpetrator will be brought to justice, providing solace for the victims’ families and bringing an end to the torment of this unsolved tragedy.