Skip to content

The Phantom Killer: The Texarkana Moonlight Murders – A Terrifying Tale of Terror


Imagine a small town gripped by fear, terrorized by a shadowy figure lurking in the darkness. The streets are deserted after dusk, and whispers of a “Phantom Killer” fill every conversation. This is the chilling reality that engulfed Texarkana, Texas, in the summer of 1946. The Texarkana Moonlight Murders, a series of brutal attacks that left five people dead and the community traumatized, remain one of the most infamous unsolved cases in American history. This blog post aims to delve into the chilling events, the haunting mystery, and the lasting legacy of the Phantom Killer.

Table of Contents:

The Murders and Their Impact:

The Texarkana Moonlight Murders began on February 22, 1946, with the attack on a young couple parked in a secluded area. The couple, Richard L. Griffin and Polly Ann Moore, were shot at point-blank range while sitting in their car. Thankfully, both survived the encounter. However, the attack marked the beginning of a terrifying reign of terror that would continue for nearly three months.

On March 23rd, the Phantom Killer struck again, this time claiming his first victims. Jimmy Hollis and Betty Jo Booker, a young couple enjoying a moonlit drive, were brutally murdered. They were shot multiple times, and Betty Jo was even sexually assaulted. The gruesome discovery sent shockwaves through Texarkana, plunging the town into a state of panic.

The fear intensified with each subsequent attack. On April 3rd, a young couple, Virgil Starks and his fiancé, were found dead in their car. A few days later, on April 5th, another young couple, Paul Martin and his girlfriend, were shot and killed. The Phantom Killer’s pattern was chillingly consistent: he targeted young couples in secluded locations, often late at night.

The terror inflicted by the Phantom Killer extended far beyond the immediate victims. Texarkana was a small town, and the murders sent shockwaves through the entire community. Schools were closed, businesses shut down early, and residents were too afraid to leave their homes after dark. The once-vibrant town was plunged into a state of fear and paranoia, with rumors and speculation swirling through the streets. The impact of the murders on the town’s social and economic fabric was profound.

The Investigation:

In the aftermath of the first attack, law enforcement agencies immediately swung into action, launching a massive investigation to catch the Phantom Killer. Texas Rangers, FBI agents, and local law enforcement collaborated in the search for the elusive killer. They interviewed hundreds of witnesses, combed through potential leads, and scoured the crime scenes for evidence.

One of the most significant pieces of evidence in the case was the series of chilling letters sent to local newspapers. These letters, penned by the Phantom Killer himself, taunted authorities and the town. He even signed the letters with a skull and crossbones, leaving an indelible mark on the Texarkana community. While the letters provided a glimpse into the killer’s psyche and fueled public fascination, they ultimately proved unhelpful in identifying the killer.

Despite the tireless efforts of the investigators, the Phantom Killer remained elusive. The lack of concrete leads, the elusive nature of the killer, and the absence of a definitive motive hampered the investigation. The Phantom Killer, seemingly skilled in blending into the shadows and operating with chilling precision, always seemed one step ahead of the authorities.

Suspects and Theories:

Over the decades, numerous individuals have been named as potential suspects in the Texarkana Moonlight Murders, each with their own motives and connections to the crimes. However, none of these leads have ever been conclusively proven. The lack of a definitive suspect only fueled the speculation surrounding the case.

One of the most prominent theories involves a man named Youell Swinney. Swinney, a former military policeman with a history of violence, was living in Texarkana during the time of the murders. He was known for his erratic behavior and had a penchant for weapons. Swinney was investigated by authorities, but he was never charged with the crimes.

Another theory points towards a man named Kenneth McDavid. McDavid, a convicted murderer, was living in Texarkana at the time of the murders. He had a history of violence against women and was known for his cruelty. While McDavid was never formally linked to the Phantom Killer, his criminal history and proximity to the murders have made him a recurring suspect.

The Phantom Killer’s true identity remains a mystery. The lack of a definitive suspect and the absence of conclusive evidence continue to fuel speculation and debate. The enduring mystery surrounding the case continues to fascinate and terrify people to this day.

Aftermath and Legacy:

Despite the extensive investigation, the Phantom Killer was never apprehended. The case remains unsolved, leaving a chilling legacy on the town of Texarkana and the American psyche. The murders have become a permanent fixture in Texarkana’s history, shaping the city’s identity and influencing its culture.

The Texarkana Moonlight Murders have inspired numerous books, documentaries, and even works of fiction. They have become a part of the American folklore, serving as a cautionary tale about the darkness that can lurk beneath the surface of seemingly ordinary communities. The unsolved nature of the case ensures that the Phantom Killer’s story will continue to resonate with generations to come.


  • Q: Was the Phantom Killer ever identified?

    A: No, the Phantom Killer was never identified. Despite the extensive investigation, no definitive suspect was ever apprehended, and the case remains unsolved.

  • Q: What was the killer’s motive?

    A: The Phantom Killer’s motive remains unclear. Some theories suggest that he was motivated by a desire for power or control, while others speculate that he may have been driven by mental instability or a specific grudge. However, without a confirmed suspect, the true motive remains a mystery.

  • Q: Are there any unsolved mysteries related to the case?

    A: Yes, there are several unresolved mysteries related to the Texarkana Moonlight Murders. The killer’s identity remains unknown, and the lack of a definitive motive continues to fuel speculation. Additionally, the exact sequence of events, the killer’s method of transportation, and the relationship between the murders and the initial attack on Richard Griffin and Polly Ann Moore remain unanswered questions.

  • Q: Did the murders inspire any famous works of fiction?

    A: Yes, the Texarkana Moonlight Murders have inspired numerous works of fiction, including books, movies, and television shows. The most notable example is the 1994 film “The Phantom of Texarkana,” which fictionalizes the events of the murders and explores various theories surrounding the killer’s identity. The murders have also been referenced in popular culture, appearing in television shows like “Unsolved Mysteries” and “Ghost Adventures.”

  • Q: What lessons can be learned from the Texarkana Moonlight Murders?

    A: The Texarkana Moonlight Murders serve as a chilling reminder of the potential for violence and darkness that exists in even the most seemingly peaceful communities. They also highlight the importance of community support and collaboration in times of crisis. The murders underscore the challenges of investigating crimes with limited evidence, especially in the absence of a definitive motive. The case also demonstrates the enduring power of unsolved mysteries to capture the public imagination and serve as a cautionary tale for generations to come.


The Phantom Killer of Texarkana remains an enigma, his identity a chilling mystery that continues to haunt the town and captivate the world. The Texarkana Moonlight Murders are a stark reminder of the potential for evil to lurk in the shadows, forever leaving a mark on the community and serving as a chilling chapter in the annals of American crime history. The case underscores the enduring power of unsolved mysteries, captivating our imaginations and reminding us of the persistent questions that remain unanswered in the face of human darkness.