Skip to content

The Sodder Children: The Christmas Eve Mystery


On Christmas Eve 1945, a family’s joyous holiday was shattered by a devastating fire that left five children missing, sparking a mystery that continues to haunt us today. The Sodder family, residing in a small West Virginia town, lost their five youngest children in the blaze, a tragedy that would forever change their lives and ignite a relentless pursuit of answers. This blog post delves into the perplexing disappearance of the Sodder children, exploring the events of that fateful night, the various theories surrounding the case, and the lasting impact it has had on both the family and the world.

Table of Contents

The Night of the Fire

The Sodder family, consisting of George and Jennie Sodder and their nine children, had gathered for a Christmas Eve celebration in their home in Fayetteville, West Virginia. As the evening wore on, a horrifying event unfolded. Around 1:00 AM on December 25th, a fire broke out on the second floor of their home, engulfing the house in flames. While George and Jennie managed to escape with their four older children, five of their youngest children – George, Maurice, Martha, Jennie, and Louis – vanished without a trace.

The fire itself was unusual. Witnesses claimed the blaze was incredibly hot, with flames shooting high into the air. The fire department, inexplicably, took an unusually long time to arrive, and their response was deemed inadequate by many observers. The fire was quickly extinguished, leaving little evidence for a thorough investigation. This lack of thoroughness and the suspicious behavior of some individuals present that night only fueled the family’s suspicions about the cause of the fire and the fate of their children.

George Sodder, a man known for his tenacity and determination, refused to accept the official explanation of the fire as an accident. He believed the fire had been intentionally set, and he suspected a cover-up regarding his missing children. The family, heartbroken and determined, embarked on a relentless quest for answers, launching a widespread search for their children and challenging the official account of the fire.

The Missing Children

The Sodder children, all under the age of 14, were described as vibrant and cherished individuals.

  • George Sodder Jr., the oldest of the missing children, was a 14-year-old boy known for his sense of humor and his love of playing baseball.
  • Maurice Sodder, 12 years old, was described as a kind and gentle boy who enjoyed playing music and helping around the house.
  • Martha Sodder, 10 years old, was a spirited girl with a love for singing and dancing.
  • Jennie Sodder, 8 years old, was a playful child who loved animals and enjoyed spending time with her siblings.
  • Louis Sodder, 4 years old, was the youngest of the Sodder children, known for his infectious smile and his love of playing with his toys.

Despite the family’s extensive search efforts, no trace of the children was ever found. No bodies were recovered, no eyewitness accounts of their whereabouts emerged, and no credible evidence of their fate was ever discovered. The lack of concrete evidence only deepened the mystery surrounding their disappearance, leaving their parents and the world with countless unanswered questions.

Theories and Speculations

The Sodder children’s disappearance has sparked numerous theories and speculations, ranging from the plausible to the outlandish.

Theories about the fire:

  • Accidental fire: The official investigation concluded that the fire was accidental, possibly caused by a faulty electrical connection. However, the family, citing suspicious circumstances and the lack of a thorough investigation, rejected this explanation.
  • Arson: The quick arrival of the fire department, the unusual intensity of the blaze, and the lack of a proper investigation fueled suspicions of arson. While no definitive evidence of arson has been presented, the family remained convinced that the fire was intentionally set.
  • Plane Crash: A peculiar theory suggests that a plane may have crashed into the Sodder house, causing the fire and carrying the missing children. This theory arose due to the unusual fire intensity and the presence of unidentified aircraft activity in the area around the time of the fire.

Theories about the children:

  • Abduction: The possibility of abduction remains one of the most widely discussed theories. Some believe the children were taken by a group or individual with nefarious intentions. However, no solid evidence has emerged to support this theory.
  • Cult involvement: Speculation about cult involvement arose due to the unusual nature of the fire and the lack of any trace of the children. However, this theory lacks any concrete evidence and remains largely in the realm of speculation.
  • Government involvement: Some believe the government may have been involved in the children’s disappearance, possibly due to a secret operation or a cover-up. This theory, too, lacks any substantial evidence and remains highly speculative.
  • Running away: The theory that the children ran away from home, fearing the fire, has also been considered. However, given their ages and the circumstances of the fire, this explanation seems highly unlikely.
  • Surviving the fire: Another theory suggests the children may have survived the fire and found a way to escape. While the lack of evidence makes this theory difficult to support, the Sodder family always held out hope that their children were alive.

Legacy and Lasting Impact

The Sodder children’s disappearance has left an enduring mark on their family, their community, and the world. The Sodder family, determined to find their children, never gave up hope. They spent decades searching for clues, investigating leads, and maintaining a constant presence in the media, keeping the case alive in the public consciousness.

The story of the Sodder children’s disappearance has captured the imaginations of countless individuals, becoming a part of popular culture. The case has been featured in books, documentaries, television shows, and podcasts, ensuring that their story continues to resonate with audiences across generations.

The Sodder family’s tireless pursuit of answers serves as a testament to their unwavering love for their children and their commitment to seeking truth even in the face of overwhelming grief and uncertainty. Their unwavering resolve has inspired countless others to never give up hope in the face of tragedy, reminding us of the enduring power of love and the importance of seeking justice.


  • What happened to the Sodder children? The exact fate of the children remains unknown, and the case remains unsolved.
  • Was the fire arson? While the fire was ruled accidental, there are many suspicions surrounding the blaze, including evidence of tampering with the fire. However, no definitive evidence of arson has been presented.
  • Were the children abducted? The possibility of abduction is a widely discussed theory, but no solid evidence has emerged to support it.
  • Why didn’t the family accept the official explanation? The Sodder family remained unconvinced by the official investigation, citing suspicious circumstances, inconsistent witness statements, and the lack of any evidence regarding their children’s whereabouts.
  • Is there any hope for solving the case? While hope for a definitive solution remains slim, the family continues to seek answers, and the case itself serves as a reminder of the importance of pursuing truth even in the face of uncertainty.


The disappearance of the Sodder children remains one of the most baffling mysteries of the 20th century. Decades have passed, yet the unanswered questions surrounding their fate continue to haunt us. The case serves as a stark reminder of the fragility of life and the enduring power of a family’s love and determination to find answers, even in the face of immense loss. The Sodder children’s story continues to resonate with people around the world, prompting us to consider the enduring mysteries that surround us, the importance of seeking truth, and the enduring power of hope in the face of the unknown.